Your website is often the first port of call for your customers, both current or prospective. As a business owner, you have tried to make it the best it can possibly be, but can you be sure that there aren’t silly mistakes hiding in plain sight?
A slow page here, a broken contact form there, a headline that makes no sense, forcing visitors to hit the back button. All of it costs you enquiries.
That’s why we have created this checklist you can run in the time it takes to drink a coffee. Some of these fixes take five minutes. Others will reveal something more important - that there's a bigger problem underneath.
Grab your phone or open your laptop and let’s get started.
1. The five-second test
Open your homepage and imagine you've never heard of your business. Within five seconds, can you tell:
What you do
Who it's for
What to do next (call, book, buy, get a quote)
Quick fix: Rewrite your main headline so it says what you do in plain English. "Innovative solutions for tomorrow" tells nobody anything. "Bookkeeping for tradespeople across Cardiff" does.
Red flag: If you struggle to write that one clear line, the problem isn't your website. It's your messaging. No amount of polish will fix a fuzzy message.
2. Pick up your phone
There's a good chance most of your visitors are on mobile (your analytics will tell you). Open your site on your phone and check:
Text is readable without pinching and zooming
Buttons are big enough to tap with a thumb
The menu opens and closes properly
Nothing scrolls sideways or overlaps
Quick fix: Break up long paragraphs, and use your theme or site builder settings to enlarge buttons and body text.
Red flag: If the layout genuinely breaks on mobile, that's usually a theme or build issue, not something a settings tweak will cure.
3. Check your speed
Run your homepage through Google's free PageSpeed Insights tool. Visitors don't wait around, and neither does Google.
Compress large images before uploading (free tools like TinyPNG or Squoosh do this in seconds)
Delete plugins or apps you no longer use
Turn off autoplaying videos and sliders you don't need
Red flag: If your score is still poor after all that, the culprit is likely your hosting, a bloated theme or the code itself. That's a job for someone who works under the bonnet.
4. Test every form and button
This is the one that hurts. Fill in your own contact form right now.
Did the enquiry actually arrive? Check your spam folder too
Does tapping your phone number on mobile start a call?
If you sell online, can you get all the way through checkout?
Do your "Book now" and "Get a quote" buttons go where they should?
Quick fix: Update the recipient email address and add an automatic confirmation so customers know their message landed.
Red flag: A form that fails silently can lose you leads for months and you'd never know. If you find one, ask how long it's been broken.
5. Hunt down broken links
Click through every item in your main menu and footer. Then open the Page indexing report in Google Search Console (free, and you should have it) to see which pages Google tried to reach and couldn't.
All menu and footer links work
Pages you've moved or renamed redirect to their new address
No "Page not found" errors on your key pages
Quick fix: Repair any broken links in your menu, footer and buttons, and set up a redirect for every page you've moved.
Worth knowing: A handful of "not found" pages isn't a problem in itself. Pages come and go. What hurts is a broken link on your own site, where a visitor clicks and hits a dead end.
Red flag: Hundreds of errors after a redesign usually mean old pages weren't redirected, and the rankings they'd earned went with them. Recovering that properly takes expertise.
6. Make sure your details are current
It sounds obvious. It's also wrong on a surprising number of sites.
Phone number, email and address are correct everywhere
Opening hours are up to date
Details match your Google Business Profile
The copyright year in your footer isn't 2019 (it quietly tells visitors nobody's home)
7. Cover the Search Engine Optimisation (SEO) basics
You don't need to be an expert to spot the obvious gaps. Search Google for site:yourdomain.co.uk and look at how your pages appear.
Every page has its own title, not just your business name repeated
Descriptions under each result actually make someone want to click
Each page has one clear main heading
Images have short, descriptive alt text
Red flag: If you don't show up when you search for your own service and town, you need a strategy, not a tweak.
8. Security and the boring (but essential) stuff
There's a padlock in the browser bar (your site uses HTTPS)
Your CMS, theme and plugins are up to date
You have a privacy policy
Your cookie banner matches the ICO's current guidance
You know where your backups are, and that they exist
You know who has logins to your website, hosting and domain
Worth knowing: The cookie rules have moved on. In April 2026 the ICO published updated guidance on cookies and similar technologies, which covers tracking pixels too. If your banner was set up years ago and never revisited, check it against the new guidance.
For the security side, the National Cyber Security Centre's Small Business Guide sets out five quick, low-cost steps any business can take.
Red flag: If you don't know who controls your domain or hosting, fix that before anything else on this list. It's the digital equivalent of not knowing who has keys to your shop.
9. Does it still look like you?
Businesses evolve. Websites often don't.
Your logo, colours and tone match your other marketing
Team photos and bios are current
Services listed are the ones you actually offer today
Your last blog post or news item isn't years old
Red flag: If your site describes the business you were three years ago, visitors are getting the wrong first impression of the one you are now.
10. Are you measuring anything?
Can you answer these three questions right now?
How many people visited your site last month?
Where did they come from?
How many of them got in touch or bought something?
Quick fix: Make sure Google Analytics 4 is installed and set up to track enquiries.
Red flag: If you can't answer these, every decision about your website is a guess.
How did you score?
So what do your results mean?
More than seven ticks?
Nice work. Book in a check every quarter and keep it that way.
Four to seven ticks?
Just take the time to block out an afternoon. You'll see the difference.
Fewer than four?
The issues are structural. Quick fixes will only paper over the cracks.
When quick fixes aren't enough
Here's the honest bit. A checklist finds symptoms. It doesn't always find causes.
You're probably dealing with something bigger if:
You've fixed the obvious stuff but enquiries haven't moved
Your site is slow no matter what you do
You can't explain what makes you different in one sentence
You've outgrown the DIY site you built when you started
"We'll sort the website out" has been on the to-do list for over a year
That last one is worth sitting with. Every month a leaky website stays live is a month of lost leads you'll never see, from customers who went to a competitor whose site simply made more sense.
Where POW comes in
We're a founder-run creative studio based in York and London, specialising in giving clear, engaging marketing to businesses.
Our first stage is analysing your core message. Fundamentally, this is what you do, who it's for and why it matters. Then we apply this to your website, content and SEO and Answer Engine Optimisation (AEO) so your marketing brings results. When we rebuilt the online store for an art and poetry retailer, product views rose by 143%.
If you ran this checklist and found more red flags than you'd like, let's talk. Book a 20-minute marketing breakdown and we'll tell you honestly what's worth fixing yourself and where you need help.