A growing threat: generative AI’s self-consumption
If 2023 and 2024 were about racing to adopt generative AI, 2025 is the year brands confront an uncomfortable reality - AI is cannibalising itself. As models increasingly ingest AI-made content, originality is eroding, quality degrading, and brands risk regurgitating the same content as their competitors. From a marketing perspective, this directly affects search visibility, trust, and the ROI of your content engine.
What self-consumption means and why it matters
Generative models need huge volumes of human-made data to stay sharp, but that supply is tightening as the web fills with AI-generated text, images, and code. Analysts warn that models are already running short on fresh, high-quality, human data. This raises the risk of a feedback loop where models learn from synthetic content and get progressively less accurate and less original.
The result is a lack of accuracy, which ultimately makes AI dependent businesses untrustworthy. Business leaders and tech commentators alike are calling out the credibility problem as AI answers seep into everyday workflows and customer touchpoints.
The ripple effects for businesses
1) Search and discovery get noisier
As AI content floods the web, researchers and infrastructure providers are scrambling to preserve pre-AI “clean” datasets. For brands, that means more competition from low-effort AI pages and a harder battle for authority.
At the same time, standards bodies and infrastructure companies are pushing new rules to separate ‘search’ from AI answer engines so publishers can allow traditional indexing while blocking model training and AI summaries.
2) More visible AI mistakes risks your brand
From legal filings with fabricated citations to quirky, confidently incorrect AI overviews, high-profile hallucinations keep making headlines. If your brand publishes or amplifies AI-generated inaccuracies, the reputational cost can be real.
3) Compliance and governance pressure rises
Enterprise AI programs in 2025 are shifting from experimentation to governance: privacy, provenance, and model-risk management are now board-level topics. Marketing teams will be expected to prove how content was produced, vetted, and kept free of synthetic-on-synthetic contamination.
What ‘AI eating AI’ looks like in practice
Declining originality: When models are trained on derivative content, outputs converge, and your differentiation blurs, even if you prompt well. Teams end up shipping sound-alike copy, artwork, and product marketing.
Compound error: Synthetic inputs amplify small mistakes into big ones (such as misattributed quotes or invented sources) especially in research-heavy content.
Quality volatility in AI surfaces: AI summaries in search and on platforms can still produce odd or incorrect results. If you rely on those surfaces for acquisition, expect variability and monitor closely.
Avoiding the AI trap
1) Don’t forget the human touch.
Use AI for speed but gate every publish with human fact-checking.
2) Tune for authority, not just volume.
Consolidate thin, AI-produced pages into comprehensive, expert resources. Lean into first-party data (surveys, telemetry, customer interviews) and original visuals. These hold up better as AI content scales.
3) Invest in human expertise as a feature.
Put named experts front-and-center (author bios, video explainers, webinars). In a world of homogenised outputs, recognised human authority is a durable differentiator.
How POW can help
POW will protect your brand from inaccurate AI by implementing provenance-first workflows with human review and rigorous editorial quality assurance, and by deploying AI-aware SEO. We have the expertise to build technical and content strategies for a mixed search/AI landscape with continuous monitoring and rapid iteration as standards evolve.
—
Generative AI isn’t going away, but letting AI train on AI without safeguards will corrode the very originality your brand depends on. The most successful businesses will pair smart automation with human judgment, proprietary insight, and rigorous governance.
If you want to future-proof your content engine against AI’s self-consumption, and grow authority while competitors churn out sameness, let’s talk.
